Aldon Smith Arrested for DUI … Again

San Francisco 49ers linebacker Aldon Smith

Aug 8, 2013; San Francisco, CA, USA; San Francisco 49ers linebacker Aldon Smith (99) on the sideline during the fourth quarter against the Denver Broncos at Candlestick Park. The Denver Broncos defeated the San Francisco 49ers 10-6. Kelley L Cox-USA TODAY Sports

Aldon Smith is, without a doubt, one of this most talented players in the NFL today, and an early candidate for defensive player of the year. He’s a key cog in the 49ers pass rush, and a budding young star with the sky as his limit.

He’s also, apparently, lacking any sort of common sense or self-preservation instincts away from the football field.

Early Friday morning, Smith was arrested on suspicion of DUI in San Jose. He was involved in a one-car accident in which no one was hurt, but a breath sample taken was over the legal limit for driving. He was also reportedly found with marijuana – which he does not have a prescription for – and pills of some nature in the car. (h/t

This would be bad enough on its own – there is absolutely no excuse for drinking and driving. None. Yes, it seems somewhat likely, albeit speculative, that he was drinking the night before, as opposed to having a couple beers before work, and still had alcohol in his system in the morning. That still doesn’t excuse it – the rest of adult society seems to manage to get to work each morning without crashing into any trees. However, if this was his first incident or the only off-field situation he had ever found himself involved in, perhaps you could say thank god no one was injured, now let’s treat this a learning experience and a teachable moment.

This isn’t Smith’s first run-in with the law, however. Nor is it his first situation involving alcohol and cars.

In January 2012, Aldon Smith was in Miami, and was arrested for DUI. The charges were later reduced to reckless driving after he took a course involving alcohol education, community service, and fines. It’s still on his record, however, and could lead to enhanced penalties for this DUI arrest, assuming it stays as such as the story develops. Apparently, the alcohol education didn’t stick – or at least, he skipped the part about how long it takes the body to process alcohol and return your blood alcohol content to safe levels.

That’s just scraping the surface, however. Smith’s been involved in at least five off-field headline grabbing incidents just since being drafted. In June of 2012, he was stabbed while fighting at a party in his house. In September of 2012, he was involved in a car wreck as a passenger when they had to swerve to avoid a deer. In September of this year, he was sued for creating a situation that resulted in a shooting – at the same house party he was stabbed at, the lawsuit alleges, Smith knew there were gang members and people armed with weapons at the party.  He’s also under investigation by the Santa Clara police about some assault weapons, which he purchased legally in Arizona but did not modify to meet California’s stricter gun laws.

It is possible to explain away most of these incidents in a vacuum, or at least see them in the most positive light—he was stabbed trying to prevent a fight from escalating, for example, or may not have known about the rules about modifying weapons and thus made an honest mistake. When put all together, however, it creates a disturbing pattern of someone who keeps placing himself in dangerous situations—situations where he is fortunate that no one else has been seriously injured, much less himself. He’s not the only 49ers player to have incidents involving alcohol and cars—even head coach Jim Harbaugh, when he was coaching at San Diego State, was caught with alcohol in his system—but he is the only one with a repeated history of doing so.

There’s just no excuse. The NFL Player Association provides a special car service for players who are too drunk to drive, available 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365 days a year. That’s even excluding the more common-man options, such as using a taxi. Smith’s already been busted once for drunk driving; you’d think that would make more careful about avoiding that in the future. Instead, he seems to have extended his repertoire—not only is he a danger to quarterbacks on the field, he seems dead set on becoming a danger to everyone off the field. There is simply no excuse for anyone to have this many incidents, or to ever get behind the wheel of a car while intoxicated. None.

What will happen to Smith now?

The first thought that comes to mind is the case of Von Miller, who is suspended for six games for a violation of the substance abuse policy. This arrest will be under review by the NFL for sure, but the 49ers shouldn’t wait that long.

They currently have issued a statement, saying “the 49ers organization is aware of the matter involving Aldon Smith. As we continue to gather information regarding this situation, we will have no further comment.” They have, however, set a precedent.

Last season, 49ers player DeMarcus Dobbs was arrested after a single-car accident for driving under the influence. He was subsequently not brought to the 49ers next game, essentially serving a team-imposed one game suspension. He was later suspended by the NFL for one game. The 49ers should use this precedent, and not suit Smith up for Sunday’s game against the Indianapolis Colts. The NFL should do their due diligence and issue the same sort of suspension—perhaps longer than one game due to his repeated incidents but short of Miller’s six game suspension due to the different circumstances.

Perhaps some on-field punishment for his transgressions will help Smith learn that his off-field incidents are simply not acceptable. He needs to stop putting himself into situations where bad things happen, and he needs to make smarter choices. The only thing, it seems, that can stop Smith from being a force on the field is his own choices off of it.

Bryan Knowles is a writer and hopelessly devoted sports nut, with strong opinions that are subject to revision near-daily. A graduate of UC Davis and San Jose State University, Bryan spends his days teaching high school English and his nights watching far too many sporting events.